The story continues with Tally now as a pretty. She turned herself in to get the operation so that the Smokies could test out the cure on her. She has been Pretty for about a month when the novel starts, and is living in New Pretty Town with all the other new pretties, including Peris and Shay. All she wants in her new life is to become a member of their clique, the Crims. She is at a party the night she hopes to be voted in, when suddenly, something from her Ugly life turns up. Or, I guess I should say, someone. An Ugly that she remembers is at the party following her around, and she can’t understand why he is there and won’t leave her alone. Tally briefly talks to him and he tells her he will leave something for her to find.
She starts to think a little clearer, and with the help of one of her fellow Crims, Zane, she gets through a series of tasks to discover that what is left for her is the cure for being “Pretty-minded.” From there on, Tally and Zane are inseparable, doing everything together and fighting to stay “bubbly” and not to fall back into the easy, Pretty haze. They plot an escape from New Pretty Town, but it becomes increasingly difficult, and there doesn’t seem to be any further help from her Ugly friends on the outside. Finally she and Zane enlist more of their fellow Crims to devise a plan that they think will work.
Not surprisingly, the plan doesn’t go exactly as expected, and Tally finds herself alone facing challenges she never would have dreamed of. She learns even more about the operations that the Specials are involved in, and more about the true nature of humanity. Tally must use her new non-Pretty brain to figure out how to join the rest of her group before they have to leave her and she is stuck alone forever. To me, this second book reminded me a lot of the second book of the Matched series, Crossed. I am excited to see what ends up happening in the third book because the end of Pretties was as much of a cliffhanger as the end of Uglies was. Really fun read, and I can’t wait to continue on with Specials!